At the Council Special Meeting on February 13, 2024, the Redmond City Council approved the transfer of land at 16725 Cleveland Street to Plymouth Housing. The meeting memo described the total cost as follows: “Redmond purchased the parcel at 16725 Cleveland Street for $5.5 million in 2019 from King County Housing Authority. In addition to the land, the City would contribute approximately $3 million out of funds set aside for affordable housing which was the contribution the City of Kenmore was making to the project.”

At the Committee of the Whole – Public Safety and Human Services meeting on April 16, 2024, city staff provided a Permanent Supportive Housing Quarterly Update. Among the updates was a  PLYMOUTH HOUSING FUNDING COMMITMENTS table, which compared funding between the Kenmore and Redmond locations. The table listed Redmond’s funding commitment as $5.5 million for the land and $3.2 million in funding, totaling $8.7 million.

In a July 19,2024 ARCH letter from Redmond Planning Director Carol Helland, acting as ARCH Executive Board Chair, she included a funding table that listed Redmond’s commitment to the Plymouth Housing project as $8,900,000, which is $200,000 more than what city staff reported in April.

Noticing the discrepancy, many contacted Redmond City Council and demanded a correction.

On September 30, 2024, Council President Vanessa Kritzer responded to the public, blaming the real estate market for the $200,000 discrepancy. Kritzer wrote, “The amount of land remains the same, but the value of the land has been increased based on a new appraisal which estimates its current worth as $5.7 million. If you see in the materials you quoted, the value of the land in April was estimated at $5.5 million and now it is estimated at $5.7 million. This accounts for the $200,000 increase you identified. “

However, at the February 13, 2024, council special meeting, Director Helland informed the council and the public that the Cleveland parcel was purchased in 2019 for $5.5 million and “it is assessed now at about $4.6 million.” 

The $5.5 million land purchase price, a fixed figure, was used to calculate Redmond’s $8.7 million commitment ($5.5 million for the land + $3.2 million in funding). To justify the additional $200,000, Council President Kritzer now claims that the land’s appraised value was used to reach the $8.9 million figure. What was the rationale for switching to the fluctuating appraised value instead of the fixed, transparent purchase price?

If Kritzer’s claim of the $5.7 million “new” valuation in July were true, it would mean a 24% increase in the parcel’s value in just five months between February and July. Does that seem reasonable?

This is not the first time Council President Kritzer has lied to the public. The bigger question is: What is she trying to hide? — ARCH had already budgeted the money in Plymouth Housing’s development costs. Had the public not discovered this discrepancy, the extra $200,000 would have quietly gone to Plymouth Housing without anyone noticing. Now that they’ve been caught, they’re scrambling to offer poor excuses.